I agree and disagree with you on this one Carl.

First of all I agree with 95% of everything you say regarding the 50mm f2.8 AF macro. I have the older version, but they are all great lenses and everyone should have one, not only for macro work but when the need arises to photograph flat artwork. These macros excel at even, distortion free, corner to corner coverage because of their flat field of focus design.

Where I differ with your opinion is the use of this lens in portraiture. Technically, YES, any lens can take a portrait and a flat field of focus is not a bad idea if you are trying for a soft focus of facial features with sharp detail of the eyes. But that particular technique is almost exclusively for photographing women and infants.

A sharp portrait of a male subject is usually the preferred methodology in portraiture and almost impossible with the shallow depth of field inherent in flat field of focus macro lenses. Thusly that is why I also carry a 50mm f:1.7 which can perform the task very well and a bit longer like an 85 would be even better.

So Yes any lens can take a portrait but not all lenses can take a good portrait. ;-)

Just had to state that! It goes back forty years to my formal education. . .

Reply

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • In forums, registered users can post images by merely pasting the image urls(max eight images) from wherever they are hosted.
    Example of url to paste: http://your-web-hosts-name.com/your-image-name.jpg

    If your images do not display some hosts such as PBase require you use special links or similar, to show images offsite.
    If posting from Flickr be sure to post the direct url including file extension(right click copy image location), not just the directory.
    Links with unusual special characters or that are extremely long, will likewise not display.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
Sorry spammers make us have to do this. If you can't read it, there is a reload button to get a new one.